Judy brings these perspectives in appreciating koan practice (inhabiting a zen story) and group dialogue in interplay with the heart of our practice, zazen. Our teachers have also practiced and and are informed by various contemporary modalities including Byron Katie’s The Work and Voice Dialogue. It may be helpful to consider that there are two basic definitions of the verb “realize.” One is “to grasp or understand clearly”; the other is “to make real.” Both are valid and each is necessary for a complete understanding of just what “realization” is. I have a YouTube channel now! 2, 19. The Rinzai tradition holds that the experience of realization (kensho, satori, awakening, enlightenment) is of central importance, for this experience is what ends suffering. 6813 Fifth Street, Washington, DC 20042 . The Rinzai Line is one of the Five Houses of Zen, best thought of as teaching styles that developed within the Zen school, following a great master. Check it out! In Rinzai Zen, the question parts of the koans are often assigned to students to meditate upon. July 1969. Masters (So)zan and (To)zan are credited with co-founding the Soto School and Master Rinzai gave his name to the Rinzai school. The two main forms of Zen Buddhism are Soto and Rinzai. Realization is primarily viewed as an event which one “has,” an event that represents or leads to a radical shift in one’s understanding about who they are and what reality is. I trained in Soto Zen, while Shozan trained in Rinzai Zen. The historical development of the Zen School is well documented. The primary practice of Soto is zazen, but it is a zazen not aimed at accomplishing anything. The Japanese Soto school was profoundly influenced by Masters Dogen, who brought the tradition from China in the 13th century and wrote about it extensively, and Keizan, who popularized it nearly 100 years later. Recognizing also the The recognition of the true nature of oneself and the universe is the aim of Rinzai Zen—but that experience, known as kensho , is really just the beginning of a life of refining that discovery and putting it into practice in the world. But Sasaki is most famous these days for the high-profile sex scandal he was involved in. Rinzai Zen was first introduced to the West through the writing of D.T. Sōtō Zen or the Sōtō school (曹洞宗, Sōtō-shū) is the largest of the three traditional sects of Zen in Japanese Buddhism (the others being Rinzai and Ōbaku).It is the Japanese line of the Chinese Cáodòng school, which was founded during the Tang dynasty by Dòngshān Liánjiè.It emphasizes Shikantaza, meditation with no objects, anchors, or content. Dogen who became a well-respected monk, founded the Zen Soto school with emphasis on shikantaza. We’ve also talked about his teacher, Joshu Sasaki. It is zazen without a goal. Still, what else can you call them? “The word Zen has become an inkblot upon which the West projects its myriad notions of peace, relaxation, and personal fulfillment, usually to commercial ends (there’s a Zen Tanning Salon in LA, after all.) I’m doing an on-stage discussion tonight at 7:30 at Against the Stream Hollywood (4300 Melrose Ave.) with Shozan Jack Haubner, author of the books Single White Monk and Zen Confidential. It’s one of those topics that touches on a wide range of issues and shouldn’t be turned into a simple good vs. evil equation. This realization (in the sense of having an experience), completing a koan curriculum, or receiving dharma transmission is not a final goal in Rinzai, for one continues to practice, to do zazen, to deepen his or her realization, and to help others. Shobogenzo translated by Gudo Nishijima & Chodo Cross Vol. But I fear that even saying that much might get me in trouble. Shozan writes at length about the Sasaki sex scandal in his book. These approaches are consistent with Dogen’s assertions of non-duality, such as “practice is realization” and “zazen itself is satori.” Tony’s teaching approach is within this shikantaza/genjokoan tradition of Soto Zen. Hakuun Yasutani had his first sesshin with Harada Sogaku Roshi in 1954 and, two years later, experienced kensho at the age of 42. I’m interested in talking about this stuff, but maybe not on stage. While the heart of the Soto school is based on the practice of Zazen, the heart of the Rinzai school focuses on the use of koan, a kind of absurd phrase or statement which is given by a teacher to a disciple to trigger Enlightenment. Was Hakuin Ekaku (1686 – 1768), the great Japanese revitalizer of Rinzai Zen and the inspiration for much of modern-day kōan introspection, a hater of We’ve talked a lot about Zen practice. They were always just publicity stunts intended to boost both stations’ ratings. Rinzai Zen Buddhism The practice of Zen Buddhism in Japan was developed through Mahayana Buddhism in China and inspired by the travels and teachings of Dogen and Eisai. Account & Lists Account Returns & Orders. In—in America, between Rinzai Zen and Sōtō Zen there—there must be some clear understanding of—of the two, or relationship of the two. Rinzai emphasizes the first definition and Soto emphasizes the second, but each school acknowledges the validity of both. A bibliography is appended. Hello, Sign in. San Francisco. Most teachers require that their students go through a curriculum of koans as part of their training before they are qualified to receive dharma transmission. Soto Zen Buddhist Association Lineage Chart by Charlie Korin Pokorny. These were called “koans” too. 506 Washington, DC 20005 . The modern Japanese Rinzai tradition was profoundly influenced by Master Hakuin in the early 1700’s. He and I became friends after that. Rinzai Zen sucks, but I still need to make a living after I mope the floor with Shozan. I don’t know if the audience at Against the Stream will be interested in that stuff. The Rinzai tradition is named for the Chinese Master of the same name in Japanese (Lin-chi, in Chinese), while Soto takes its name from the first two letters of Masters Sozan (Ts’ao-shan Pen-chi) and his teacher, Tozan (Tung-shan Liang-chieh). Buddhist Group Washington, DC. Rather than being a special event, awakening is seen primarily as an ongoing process, always and constantly occurring here and now, always exactly at the point of the interdependent encounter between “you” and “the universe” as it is experienced in your ever-changing awareness, here and now. Stay up to date on my live appearances and more by signing up for our mailing list on the contact page! Shozan’s teacher liked to make up his own questions for students to answer at sanzen. It’s nothing like the animosity between Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland. I’ve got a new book out now! 1407 West 2nd Street, Los Angeles, CA, 90026 Beginners only! Many koans center on a question that seems to be absurd, unanswerable, or both. Baldy Zen Center, Mt Baldy, CA, November 10-12, 2017 Non-Residential Retreat, Toronto, ON, Canada, November 14, 2017 Lecture, Dawson College, Montreal, QC, Canada. 1407 West 2nd Street, Los Angeles, CA, 90026 Beginners only! ↳ Zen ↳ Chan ↳ Seon ↳ Rinzai ↳ Soto ↳ Thien ↳ Pure Land ↳ Jodo Shin Shu ↳ Tendai ↳ Nichiren ↳ Soka Gakkai/SGI ↳ Nichiren Shu ↳ Nichiren Shoshu ↳ Shingon ↳ Sūtra Studies ↳ Academic Discussion; General Dharma ↳ Dharma in Everyday Life ↳ Help Required ↳ Dharma Events DON’T BE A JERK is now available as an audiobook from Audible.com as are Hardcore Zen and Sit Down and Shut Up and There is No God and He is Always With You! It’s also really hard to talk about. Practitioners of Soto Zen believed that Rinzai koans had become a formal technique. Zen Videos Every Saturday at 10:00 am there’s zazen at the Angel City Zen Center (NEW PLACE!) The Rinzai Zen Way is a thorough and accessible primer on the history, principles, and practices of authentic Rinzai Zen Buddhism. Containers That Don’t Hold: Soto and Rinzai Zen March 10, 2009 Dosho Port. Unlike Soto Zen, which is more or less organized under the authority of the Soto Shu organization, Rinzai in Japan is a tradition of informally affiliated temples teaching Hakuin's Rinzai Zen. Where will it go? This article is about the Chinese origins of Rinzai Zen. I met Shozan at Mount Baldy Zen Center where he was a monk for a very long time. Kobun Chino (My 1st Zen Teacher Tim McCarthy's Teacher), 17. How has the Sanbo-kyodan (now called Sanbo Zen) influence became the seed for much of what is now experienced as Zen in America? Articles and Essays by Nishijima Roshi, 13. At Mt. The two most famous collections are the Pi-yen-lu, the “Blue Cliff Record” and the Mumonkan, the “Gateless Gate.” Typically, a koan is assigned by a teacher to a student who then “works” on the koan until it is “solved” to the satisfaction of the teacher. I wonder if that’s the right word, since the word koan usually refers only to the traditional “public cases” of ancient masters. UPCOMING EVENTS (ALL ARE OPEN TO EVERYBODY), October 25, 2017 7:30 pm Battle with Shozan Jack Haubner at Against the Stream, Los Angeles, CA, November 3-5, 2017 Retreat at Mt. Rinzai One of the two main schools of Zen still active in Japan, the other being Sōtō. Every Monday at 7:30pm there’s zazen at Angel City Zen Center (NEW TIME, NEW PLACE!) This experience is something that is seen, at least initially, as a goal of practice. They thought that by putting too much emphasis on koans, the students of Rinzai Zen would be distracted by the urge to find an “answer” to the riddles by using mental faculties or the intellect, which, they believed, was opposed to the intuitive nature of Zen. Although my book Zen Wrapped in Karma Dipped in Chocolate does address some of that stuff. What little I know about it comes mostly from Soto Zen teachers denouncing it. What little I know about it comes mostly from Soto Zen teachers denouncing it. The two schools are not incompatible; their commonalities far outweigh their differences, and some Zen teachers combine both approaches, particularly those within the Harada-Yasutani lineage. Its initial introduction near the end of the 12th century did not take hold, but a subsequent transfer from China did succeed. Koan means “public case.” Most are stories of encounters between Zen practitioners and the often bizarre conversations they have with each other. 1, 18. Is it cultural appropriation? The Zen Community of Oregon is rooted in our Soto and Rinzai Zen heritage with influences from teachings and practice in various traditions of Buddhism. Hybrid Zen: Rinzai and Soto Merged Yasutani Hakuun (born in 1885) was an unusual Japanese student who became a monk at 11 years of age, was ordained (in Soto Zen) at 13, and attained kensho at 42. Baldy, Shozan went by his actual dharma name, Gento. 1101 L Street NW, Apt. women, Judy learned expressions of Zen, which include Soto and Rinzai practice, and integrate arts, inter-religious dialogue, social justice, and peacebuilding. Dec 30, 2018 - Explore Zen Niche's board "Rakusu" on Pinterest. My current book, which I’m also eager to sell tonight, doesn’t have any sex at all in it, sadly. There has always been a rivalry between the two types of Zen in Japan. In the formal sense, koans are cases of life-changing encounters between Zen masters and disciples in ancient China during the “golden age” of Zen. I’ve never practiced Rinzai Zen. Dae Do Sah of Falls Church [Korean Zen] Note that many temples near Washington DC (such as Silver Spring MD and Germantown MD) are within an hour drive from Baltimore, so please see our main listing for more. Bright Pearl Zen Group of Washington. Listen to this talk: Suzuki-roshi 69-07-00 . To say Rinzai "stresses" koans over Zazen would be inaccurate. It contains his RINNOU NET | English Site; japanese; chinese; sitemap; what is Zen ? Try Prime It also recognized that some shift in one’s understanding is necessary, but that shift need not be dramatic or “special.” Soto holds that what is centrally important is ongoing actualization of realization. It was brought to Japan in the 13th century. This page is for Buddhist/meditation groups and temples in Maryland not near the Washington DC area (mostly in Baltimore). There are a lot of forms of Buddhism, of which Zen Buddhism is just one. It is part of the Sanbo Kyodan (Order of the Three Treasures), a lay stream of Soto Zen wthat includes aspects of Rinzai Zen (the two main schools of Japanese Zen). Hybrid Zen: Rinzai and Soto Merged Yasutani Hakuun (born in 1885) was an unusual Japanese student who became a monk at 11 years of age, … Gudo Nishijima's Blog (my ordaining Zen teacher), 09. They are expected to demonstrate their answers to these questions in a ritual called sanzen, in which they present their responses to their teacher for their teacher’s evaluation. Awakening, at least in part, is the experiential “waking up” to that fact and to this ongoing flow of your life, which will consist of both “special” and “ordinary” moments. The most famous of these are, “It is said that everything has Buddha Nature, does even a dog have Buddha Nature?” and “We all know the sound of two hands clapping, what’s the sound of one hand?”. Shunryū Suzuki-Roshi. Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! It reminds me of the fake “wars” that used to erupt between rival radio DJ’s in Ohio. The other difference is that the Rinzai people tend to place a great deal of value on satori, or “enlightenment experiences,” while in Soto Zen they say that sitting zazen is, itself, enlightenment already — even if you don’t notice it. People love to talk about Zen and read about it, but not many actually want to do it. So I won’t be in a great hurry to talk about the scandal tonight. I’d like to talk about the nature and meaning of “enlightenment.” But I doubt that’s what will happen. He was one of the people tasked with cooking food and helping out when my Zen group rented Mt. See more ideas about zen, japanese silk, soto zen. Shobogenzo translated by Gudo Nishijima & Chodo Cross Vol. Bien que l'école Rinzai – également issue d'une branche du zen chinois – ait eu l'appui et la confiance du gouvernement shogunal, de la noblesse et des personnes influentes, l'école Sôtô avait pour fidèles les familles aisées des districts ruraux, ainsi que des gens ordinaires. There are two major schools of Japanese Zen, called Soto and Rinzai, which originated in China. Rinzai Zen lineages 逓代伝法佛祖の名号 Teidai Denpō Busso no Myōgō . Details below. The major differences between Soto and Rinzai is that Soto practitioners face the wall while sitting, while Rinzai people face away from the wall; Rinzai people typically sit for periods of 20-25 minutes, while in Soto Zen you usually sit for 30-40 minute periods; and they each use the koan stories differently. It’s mostly just one side trash talking the other, while realizing their similarities far outweigh their differences. Dogen, the founder of the Japanese branch of Soto, commented on a lot of koans in his masterwork Shobogenzo. My first teacher studied for a short time with Sasaki, and Sasaki’s book Buddha is the Center of Gravity remains one of my favorites. The origin of these two traditions dates to about the 8th century in China, when many dynamic individual teachers began to put their various stamps on Zen practice. I’d love to talk with Shozan tonight about the differences between Rinzai and Soto practice. In Soto Zen, the koan stores are often discussed or commented upon. Suzuki , and Rinzai Zen is being taught and practiced in the Americas, Australia, and Europe. Members in each lineage are displayed in a box (or boxes) in alphabetical order. The Soto tradition does not deny that many people have special experiences of realization but does see the seeking of them to be problematic. Meido Moore is having none of this. What will it be in the future? I trained in Soto Zen, while Shozan trained in Rinzai Zen. Both Rinzai and Soto Zen Buddhists study koans and practice Zazen. I’ve never practiced Rinzai Zen. We are a Soto Zen Buddhist temple. Rather than being guided by trying to “get” or “attain” something, the practitioner is guided by the intention of simply being aware of what is actually occurring in the eternal “present moment.” This type of zazen is called shikantaza, which translates as “just sitting.” In addition to shikantaza zazen, Soto emphasizes what Dogen called genjokoan, the realization that everything we do is an expression of ultimate reality and an opportunity to awaken. If you find a little bit of truth in what I’m saying remember that even a small donation helps. Shobogenzo translated by Gudo Nishijima & Chodo Cross Vol. Morning. Although Eisai is credited with being the first Japanese Linji lineage holder, he did not establish a surviving Rinzai Zen lineage or a Rinzai Zen school independent from Tendai. The two main forms of Zen Buddhism are Soto and Rinzai. The primary differences between the two schools are in their approaches to realization and their practice methods. Plenty more info is available on the Dogen Sangha Los Angeles website, dsla.info. Zen Buddhism usually means Japanese Zen, although there is also Chinese, Korean and Vietnamese Zen, called Chan, Seon and Thien, respectively. I’m sure we’ll also have to get into Joshu Sasaki’s sex scandal and sex scandals in Western Buddhism in general. Since ATS is not even in the Zen lineage at all, these things might be totally irrelevant to them. It’s also nearly impossible to address this subject without getting someone in the audience riled up — especially in light of the current “national conversation” about Harvey Weinstein. I had no idea he was Shozan Jack Haubner until I brought up the subject of the book Zen Confidential, which I liked a lot, and he admitted to being the author. Thank you! As for the practice of Soto Zen, it spread in the West from the 1960s, first in the USA then in Europe with the arrival in Paris of Master Taisen Deshimaru in 1967. Shobogenzo translated by Gudo Nishijima & Chodo Cross Vol. 3, 20. I’d like to try to dispel some of the wrong assumptions Rinzai people have about Soto practice, and have my own wrong assumptions about Rinzai practice dispelled. Instead, several other monks would lay the foundations of what would be Japanese Rinzai Zen. This is probably the most crucial and important difference, the one with the most far-reaching implications for practice. In any case, I’m looking forward to a lively talk. This site is owned and operated by Buddiyskiye Fanaty Kompaniya, Volgograd, Russian Federation, 06. You can find some of these commentaries in my new book, It Came from Beyond Zen. Besides which, I would hate to devote the entire 90 minutes we’ve been allotted to discussing it. 4, There is No God and He is Always With You. Rinzai, with There are two main schools of Zen Buddhism flourishing today, Soto and Rinzai, both of which gained their names from the Chinese masters who founded the schools. The differences are in the relative importance in day-to-day practice. 162 were here. Your donations are my main means of supporting my teaching. But it’s a friendly rivalry. In addition to zazen, attention to daily life, and intellectual study, Rinzai employs the intense examination of koans as an important, perhaps the most important aspect of practice. Tradition: Zen Buddhist Master Thich Nhat Hahn (702) 812-9106. pfquerrero@aol.com. Rinzai's "Record" was written by his disciples. This lineage chart displays the lineages of active members of the SZBA as of Sept 18, 2008. There haven’t been any Soto crusades to convert the Rinzais and kill those who refuse to submit. New River Zen Community (NRZC) [Soto/Rinzai Zen] Contact: Ellen Birx Phone: (540) 605-7560 Email: cbirx@verizon.net Potomac Zen Sangha [Zen] Location: 1423 Powhatan St, Suite #7, Alexandria, VA 22314 Mailing Address: 11955 Governors Court, Woodbridge, VA 22192 Contact: Pohwa Sunim at Potomaczen@yahoo.com . What is it now? Read Part 1 of this short series for insight into Soto and Rinzai Zen. Rinzai, which originated in China, was the first school of Zen to be brought to Japan. It was more or less an intellectual approach based on the Rinzai Zen tradition. The following is an oversimplification of their differences but can serve as an introduction. While, in Dogen, Soto Zen had one founder, Rinzai had several. Baltimore Dharma Group 220 Wendover Road,… For all the press it gets, Zen Buddhism appears to me to be one of the least popular forms of Buddhism in terms of actual practice. It is recognized that there can be many levels of profundity of such an experience, so it is one which can be accurately evaluated and confirmed only by one who has also “had” this shift, i.e., one’s master. These on-going events happen every week even if I am away from Los Angeles. Tradition: Soto/Rinzai Zen (202) 722-1511. danbruner@aol.com. The Rinzai tradition is named for the Chinese Master of the same name in Japanese (Lin-chi, in Chinese), while Soto takes its name from the first two letters of Masters Sozan (Ts’ao-shan Pen-chi) and his teacher, Tozan (Tung-shan Liang-chieh). Is it legitimate? The ''Falaise Verte'' Zen Centre is part of the Rinzai School of Zen Buddhism and is located in the Ardeche area in the south of France. It is accurate to say that Soto Zen considers the practice of Zazen to be the sole means of realization. Baldy Zen Center for a retreat a few years ago. One thing that I think may be relevant to all of us is Buddhism in America, or Buddhism in the West in general. So, OK, I’ll call those “koans” too. Shozan and I have talked about that too.